人工智能（AI）采用与组织效率：组织学习能力的中介作用与数字素养的调节作用——基于加纳银行业的实证研究 - 生物通

Кратко: È˹¤ÖÇÄÜ£¨AI£©²ÉÓÃÓë×é֯ЧÂÊ£º×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦µÄÖнé×÷ÓÃÓëÊý×ÖËØÑøµÄµ÷½Ú×÷Ó᪡ª»ùÓÚ¼ÓÄÉÒøÐÐÒµµÄʵ֤Ñо¿ ¡¶Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence¡·£ºArtificial intelligence adoption and organizational efficiency: the mediating role of organizational learning capability and moderating role of digital literacy ±à¼ÍƼö£º ¡¡¡¡ÒýÑÔ£ºÓÉÓÚÈ«Çò¶ÔÊý×Ö»¯×ªÐÍ¡¢³ÖÐøÔËӪЧÂÊÒÔ¼°È˹¤ÖÇÄÜ£¨Artificial Intelligence, AI£©¼¼Êõ¿ìËÙ·¢Õ¹µÄÐèÇó£¬Õ½ÂÔÓë×éÖ¯½â¾ö·½°¸Õý±äµÃ²»¿É»òȱ¡£±¾Ñо¿¿¼²ìÈ˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓã¨AI adoption£©¶Ô×é֯ЧÂÊ£¨organizational eff ¡¡¡¡ ÒýÑÔ£ºÓÉÓÚÈ«Çò¶ÔÊý×Ö»¯×ªÐÍ¡¢³ÖÐøÔËӪЧÂÊÒÔ¼°È˹¤ÖÇÄÜ£¨Artificial Intelligence, AI£©¼¼Êõ¿ìËÙ·¢Õ¹µÄÐèÇó£¬Õ½ÂÔÓë×éÖ¯½â¾ö·½°¸Õý±äµÃ²»¿É»òȱ¡£±¾Ñо¿¿¼²ìÈ˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓã¨AI adoption£©¶Ô×é֯ЧÂÊ£¨organizational efficiency£©µÄÓ°Ï죬ÆäÖÐÊý×ÖËØÑø£¨digital literacy£©×÷Ϊ±ß½çÌõ¼þ£¨boundary condition£©£¬×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦£¨organizational learning capability, OLC£©×÷ΪÖнé±äÁ¿£¨mediator£©¡£·½·¨£ºÑо¿²ÉÓö¨Á¿ºá¶ÏÃæµ÷²éÉè¼Æ£¨quantitative cross-sectional survey design£©¡£²ÉÓöà½×¶Î³éÑù¼¼Êõ£¨multistage sampling technique£©´Ó¼ÓÄÉÒøÐÐÒµÔ±¹¤ÖÐÊÕ¼¯Êý¾Ý¡£ÀûÓôÓÒøÐÐ388ÃûÔ±¹¤ÊÕ¼¯µÄÊý¾Ý£¬²ÉÓýṹ·½³ÌÄ£ÐÍ£¨structural equation modeling, SEM£©½øÐÐʵ֤Ñо¿¡£ÆÀ¹ÀÁËÖ±½ÓÓë¼ä½Ó¹Øϵ¡£½á¹û£ºÑо¿·¢ÏÖ£¬È˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓÃˮƽ¶Ô×é֯ЧÂʺÍ×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦¾ù¾ßÓÐÏÔÖøÇÒÕýÏòµÄÓ°Ïì¡£½á¹û½øÒ»²½±íÃ÷£¬×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦¶Ô×é֯ЧÂʾßÓÐÏÔÖøÇÒÕýÏòÓ°Ï죬²¢²¿·ÖÖнéÈ˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓÃÓë×é֯ЧÂÊÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ¡£´ËÍ⣬½á¹û±íÃ÷£¬Êý×ÖËØÑøµ÷½ÚÈ˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓÃÓë×é֯ЧÂÊÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ£¬ÒÔ¼°×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦Óë×é֯ЧÂÊÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ¡£½áÂÛ£º±¾Ñо¿Ìá³öÁËÒ»¸öÐÂÓ±µÄÀíÂÛ¿ò¼Ü£¬½«ÐÂÐ˾¼ÃÌåÒøÐÐÒµÖÐÈ˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓá¢×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦¡¢Êý×ÖËØÑøÓë×é֯ЧÂÊÖ®¼ä´ËÇ°±»ºöÊÓµÄÁªÏµÁ¬½ÓÆðÀ´¡£Í¨¹ý½«ÕâЩ¹¹ÄîÕûºÏµ½Ò»¸öͳһģÐÍÖУ¬Ñо¿²ûÃ÷ÁËAI²ÉÓÃת»¯Îª×é֯ЧÂʵĻúÖƺͱ߽çÌõ¼þ£¬´Ó¶øÔÚÐÂÐËÊг¡Çé¾³ÏÂÍØÕ¹ÁË×ÊÔ´»ù´¡¹Û£¨Resource-Based View, RBV£©¡£ ÂÛÎĽâ¶Á ½üÄêÀ´£¬È«ÇòÊý×Ö»¯×ªÐÍ¡¢³ÖÐøÔËӪЧÂÊÐèÇóºÍÈ˹¤ÖÇÄÜ£¨Artificial Intelligence, AI£©¼¼Êõ¿ìËÙÑݽø£¬Ê¹Õ½ÂÔºÍ×éÖ¯²ãÃæµÄ½â¾ö·½°¸³ÉΪ±ØÐè¡£ÒøÐÐÒµÖУ¬AI±»ÓÃÓÚ¸ÄÉƾö²ß¡¢¿Í»§·þÎñ¡¢ÆÛÕ©¼ì²âºÍÔËӪЧÂÊ£¬µ«AIÊÕÒæ²¢·Ç¾ùÔÈ·Ö²¼£¬Êܼ¼ÄÜȱ¿Ú¡¢»ù´¡ÉèÊ©ÏÞÖƺÍ×éÖ¯ÄÜÁ¦µÈÓ°Ïì¡£ÏÖÓÐÑо¿¶à¼¯ÖÐÓÚ¼¼ÊõÏȽø¾¼ÃÌ壬ÇÒ¶à¹Ø×¢Ïû·ÑÕß²ÉÓÃAIÇý¶¯ÒøÐзþÎñ¡¢½ðÈڿƼ¼ºÍÊý×Ö»¯Ñݽø£¬½ÏÉÙ¿¼²ìAIÈçºÎͨ¹ý×éÖ¯ÄÜÁ¦ÌáÉýÄÚ²¿×é֯ЧÂÊ¡£·ÇÖÞÒøÐÐÒµ£¬ÓÈÆä¼ÓÄÉ£¬Ïà¹Øʵ֤֤¾Ý²»×ã¡£ÒÑÓÐÎÄÏ׶ÔAIÓ°Ïì×éÖ¯¼¨Ð§µÄ»úÖƺͱ߽çÌõ¼þ½âÊͲ»×ã¡£Òò´Ë£¬Ñо¿ÈËÔ±»ùÓÚ×ÊÔ´»ù´¡¹Û£¨Resource-Based View, RBV£»ÈÏΪÓмÛÖµ¡¢Ï¡È±¡¢ÄÑÒÔÄ£·ÂºÍ²»¿ÉÌæ´ú×ÊÔ´´øÀ´³ÖÐø¾ºÕùÓÅÊƵÄÀíÂÛ£©£¬ÒýÈë×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦£¨organizational learning capability, OLC£»×éÖ¯»ñÈ¡¡¢¹²ÏíºÍÓ¦ÓÃ֪ʶµÄÄÜÁ¦£©×÷ΪÖнé±äÁ¿£¬Êý×ÖËØÑø£¨digital literacy, DL£»ÓÐЧʹÓÃÊý×Ö¹¤¾ßËùÐè¼¼ÄÜ¡¢Àí½âÓëÇãÏò£©×÷Ϊµ÷½Ú±äÁ¿£¬¿¼²ìÈ˹¤ÖÇÄܲÉÓã¨artificial intelligence adoption, AIAD£©¶Ô×é֯ЧÂÊ£¨organizational efficiency, OREFF£»ÒÔ½ÏÉÙ×ÊÔ´Ìṩ¸ßÖÊÁ¿·þÎñÓë³É¹ûµÄÄÜÁ¦£©µÄÓ°Ïì¡£Ñо¿ÎÊÌâ°üÀ¨AIADÓëOREFF¹Øϵ¡¢OLCµÄÖнé×÷ÓÃÒÔ¼°DL¶ÔAIAD¨COREFFºÍOLC¨COREFF¹ØϵµÄµ÷½Ú×÷Óá£Ñо¿Ö¼ÔÚ˵Ã÷AI²ÉÓÃÊÇ·ñ¼°ÈçºÎÌáÉý×é֯ЧÂÊ£¬²¢ÎªÐÂÐËÊг¡Ìṩ֤¾Ý¡£ Ñо¿ÈËÔ±²ÉÓö¨Á¿ºá¶ÏÃæµ÷²é£¬¶à½×¶Î³éÑù£¬´Ó¼ÓÄÉÒøÐÐÒµÔ±¹¤ÊÕ¼¯Êý¾Ý¡£ÏòÉÌÒµÒøÐÐÔ±¹¤·¢·Å500·ÝÎÊ¾í£¬»ØÊÕ393·Ý£¬ÌÞ³ý5·Ý£¬×îÖÕʹÓÃ388·ÝÓÐЧÎÊ¾í¡£Êý¾Ý·ÖÎö²ÉÓÃÆ«×îС¶þ³Ë½á¹¹·½³ÌÄ£ÐÍ£¨partial least squares structural equation modeling, PLS-SEM£©£¬ÆÀ¹ÀÖ±½ÓºÍ¼ä½Ó¹Øϵ¡£½á¹ûÏÔʾ£¬AIADÏÔÖøÕýÏòÓ°ÏìOREFFºÍOLC£»OLCÏÔÖøÕýÏòÓ°ÏìOREFF²¢²¿·ÖÖнéAIADÓëOREFF¹Øϵ£»DLµ÷½ÚAIAD¨COREFF¼°OLC¨COREFF¹Øϵ¡£Ñо¿Ìá³öÐÂÀíÂÛ¿ò¼Ü£¬½«AIAD¡¢OLC¡¢DLÓëOREFFÕûºÏ£¬²ûÃ÷AIת»¯ÎªÐ§ÂʵĻúÖƺͱ߽çÌõ¼þ£¬²¢ÔÚÐÂÐËÊг¡Çé¾³ÏÂÍØÕ¹RBV¡£Êµ¼ùÉÏ£¬ÒøÐÐÓ¦½«AIÈÚÈëºËÐÄÔËÓª£¬Í¬Ê±Ç¿»¯Ñ§Ï°»úÖƺÍÔ±¹¤Êý×Ö¼¼ÄÜ£»Õþ²ßºÍ¹ÜÀíÕßӦе÷¼¼Êõ¡¢×é֯ѧϰºÍÊý×Ö¼¼ÄÜͶ×Ê¡£ ¹Ø¼ü¼¼Êõ·½·¨°üÀ¨£º¶¨Á¿ºá¶ÏÃæµ÷²éÉè¼Æ£»¶à½×¶Î³éÑù£»Ñù±¾¶ÓÁÐÀ´Ô´Îª¼ÓÄÉ23¼ÒÉÌÒµÒøÐÐÔ±¹¤£¬×îÖÕ388·ÝÓÐЧÎÊ¾í£»²ÉÓüÆËã»ú¸¨ÖúÍøÂç·Ã̸£¨Computer-Assisted Web Interviewing, CAWI£©ÊÕ¼¯Êý¾Ý£»ËùÓй¹Äî²ÉÓÃÎ弶LikertÁ¿±í£¬Á¿±í¸Ä±à×ÔChengµÈ¡¢AtiyyahÓëS?zbilir¡¢Jerez-GomezµÈ¼°NgµÈ¡£·ÖÎöʹÓÃSPSS 23ºÍSmartPLS 4.0.1.8£¬²ÉÓÃPLS-SEMÁ½½×¶Î·¨´¦Àí¸ß½×¹¹Ähigher-order construct, HOC£©£»²âÁ¿Ä£ÐÍÆÀ¹ÀCronbach¡¯s ¦Á¡¢×éºÏÐŶȣ¨composite reliability, CR£©¡¢Æ½¾ù·½²îÌáÈ¡Á¿£¨average variance extracted, AVE£©ºÍÒìÖÊ-µ¥ÖʱÈÂÊ£¨heterotrait¨Cmonotrait ratio, HTMT£©£»½á¹¹Ä£ÐÍÆÀ¹À·½²îÅòÕÍÒò×Ó£¨variance inflation factor, VIF£©¡¢Ð§Ó¦Á¿£¨f 2£©¡¢¾ö¶¨ÏµÊý£¨R 2£©¡¢Ô¤²âÏà¹ØÐÔ£¨Q 2predict£©¼°5000´ÎBootstrapÖسéÑù¡£ Ñо¿½á¹û 4.1 ²âÁ¿Ä£ÐÍÓë³õ²½½á¹û£ºÍ¨¹ýPLS-SEMÆÀ¹À£¬±¥ºÍÄ£ÐÍSRMR=0.056¡¢NFI=0.900£¬±íÃ÷Ä£ÐÍÄâºÏÁ¼ºÃ¡£ 4.1.1 ÐŶÈÓëЧ¶È·ÖÎö£ºµÍ½×ºÍ¸ß½×¹¹ÄîµÄÍâÔغɡ¢Cronbach¡¯s ¦Á¡¢CRºÍAVE¾ù´ïµ½ÒªÇó£»ÄÚÈÝЧ¶È¾×¨¼ÒÆÀ¹À£»¸ß½×¹¹ÄîµÄµÍ½×ά¶ÈÔغÉÏÔÖø¡£ 4.1.2 Çø·ÖЧ¶È£º¸ß½×¹¹ÄîHTMTֵΪ0.414¨C0.500£¬µÍÓÚ0.85£¬Çø·ÖЧ¶È³ÉÁ¢¡£ 4.2 ½á¹¹Ä£ÐÍ£ºÑо¿ÈËÔ±ÆÀ¹À¹²Í¬·½·¨Æ«Îó¡¢¹²ÏßÐÔ¡¢f 2¡¢R 2ºÍQ 2predict¡£ 4.2.1 ¹²Í¬·½·¨Æ«Îó£ºHarmanµ¥Òò×Ó½âÊÍ36.363%·½²î£¬µÍÓÚ50%£»VIFΪ1.000¨C1.339£¬µÍÓÚ3.3£¬ÎÞÑÏÖع²Í¬·½·¨Æ«Îó»ò¹²ÏßÐÔ¡£ 4.2.2 ЧӦÁ¿£ºAIAD¡úOLCµÄf 2=0.233£¬ÎªÖеÈЧӦ£»AIAD¡úOREFFΪ0.076£¬DL¡úOREFFΪ0.108£¬OLC¡úOREFFΪ0.088£¬½»»¥ÏîΪ0.065ºÍ0.091£¬¾ùΪСЧӦ¡£ 4.2.3 Ô¤²âÏà¹ØÐÔ£ºQ 2predict¶ÔOLCΪ0.184£¬¶ÔOREFFΪ0.345£»OLCµÄRMSEºÍMAE·Ö±ðΪ0.907ºÍ0.757£¬OREFF·Ö±ðΪ0.813ºÍ0.654¡£ 4.2.4 ½âÊÍÁ¦£ºÄ£ÐͽâÊÍOLC·½²î18.9%£¨R 2=0.189£©£¬½âÊÍOREFF·½²î46.7%£¨R 2=0.467£©¡£ 4.3 ¼ÙÉè¼ìÑ飺²ÉÓÃ5000´ÎBootstrapºÍ95%ÖÃÐÅÇø¼ä¡£ 4.3.1 Ö±½ÓЧӦ£ºH 1 AIAD¡úOREFF£¨¦Â=0.233£¬t=5.030£¬p<0.001£©¡¢H 2 AIAD¡úOLC£¨¦Â=0.435£¬t=10.516£¬p<0.001£©¡¢H 3 OLC¡úOREFF£¨¦Â=0.247£¬t=5.659£¬p<0.001£©¾ù»ñÖ§³Ö£»DL¡úOREFFÖ÷ЧӦÏÔÖø£¨¦Â=0.267£¬t=5.968£¬p<0.001£©¡£ 4.3.2 ÖнéЧӦ£ºH 4 AIAD¡úOLC¡úOREFF¼ä½ÓЧӦÏÔÖø£¨¦Â=0.107£¬t=4.990£¬p<0.001£©£¬Ö±½ÓЧӦÈÔÏÔÖø£¬¹ÊΪ²¿·ÖÖн飬VAFԼΪ31.5%¡£ 4.3.3 µ÷½ÚЧӦ£ºH 5 DL¡ÁAIAD¡úOREFFÏÔÖø£¨¦Â=0.215£¬t=4.875£¬p<0.001£©£¬H 6 DL¡ÁOLC¡úOREFFÏÔÖø£¨¦Â=0.247£¬t=6.051£¬p<0.001£©£»¸ßDLÔöÇ¿AIADºÍOLC¶ÔOREFFµÄÕýÏò¹Øϵ¡£Áù¸ö¼ÙÉè¾ù»ñÖ§³Ö¡£ ÌÖÂÛ²¿·Ö×ܽ᣺Ñо¿·¢ÏÖAIADÕýÏò¹ØÁªOREFFºÍOLC£¬OLCÕýÏò¹ØÁªOREFF²¢²¿·ÖÖнéAIAD¨COREFF£¬DLµ÷½Ú²¢Ç¿»¯AIAD¨COREFFºÍOLC¨COREFF¡£ÌÖÂÛÈÏΪ£¬AI×÷ΪսÂÔ×ÊÔ´ÐèÓë×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦ºÍÊý×ÖËØÑøµÈ»¥²¹ÄÜÁ¦½áºÏ£¬·ûºÏRBV¡£ÀíÂÛÆôʾ°üÀ¨£ºAI²ÉÓñ¾Éí²»×ãÒÔÌáÉýЧÂÊ£¬ÐèÓëOLCºÍDLÕûºÏ£»ÊµÖ¤È·ÈÏOLCÊǹؼü»úÖÆ£»DLÊÇÖØÒª±ß½çÌõ¼þ£»Ìṩ¼ÓÄÉÒøÐÐÒµÐÂÐËÊг¡Ö¤¾Ý£¬ÍØÕ¹RBVÇé¾³ÊÊÓÃÐÔ¡£Êµ¼ùÆôʾ½¨ÒéÒøÐн«AIǶÈë¿Í»§·þÎñ¡¢ÆÛÕ©¼ì²â¡¢ÐÅÓÃÆÀ¹ÀºÍ¾ö²ßÖ§³Ö£¬Ç¿»¯ÖªÊ¶»ñÈ¡¡¢¹²ÏíºÍ³ÖÐøѧϰ£¬Í¶×ÊÔ±¹¤Êý×Ö¼¼ÄÜ£»Õþ²ßÖƶ¨ÕߺÍ×éÖ¯Áìµ¼ÕßӦͳ³ïAI¼¼Êõ¡¢×é֯ѧϰºÍÊý×Ö¼¼ÄÜ¡£¾ÖÏÞ°üÀ¨×îÖս׶αãÀû³éÑù¡¢ºá¶ÏÃæÉè¼Æ¡¢×Ô±¨Êý¾Ý£»Î´À´Ó¦²ÉÓøÅÂʳéÑù¡¢×ÝÏò»òÃæ°åÉè¼Æ¡¢¶àÀ´Ô´Êý¾Ý£¬²¢ÄÉÈë×éÖ¯ÎÄ»¯¡¢Áìµ¼Á¦¡¢AIÖÎÀí¡¢´´ÐÂÄÜÁ¦µÈÒòËØ£¬ÔÚ²»Í¬ÐÐÒµºÍÐÂÐ˾¼ÃÌåÑéÖ¤¡£ Ñо¿½áÂÛ·Ò룺±¾Ñо¿¿¼²ìÁ˼ÓÄÉÒøÐÐÒµÖÐÈ˹¤ÖÇÄÜ£¨AI£©²ÉÓÃÓë×é֯ЧÂÊÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ£¬Öصã¹Ø×¢×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦µÄÖнéÓ°ÏìºÍÊý×ÖËØÑøµÄµ÷½ÚЧӦ¡£½á¹û±íÃ÷£¬AIʵʩÓë×é֯ЧÂʸÄÉÆÖ±½ÓÏà¹Ø£¬²¢Í¨¹ý×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦¼ä½ÓÏà¹Ø£»Êý×ÖËØÑøÔöÇ¿ÁËAI²ÉÓúÍ×é֯ѧϰÄÜÁ¦¶Ô×é֯ЧÂʵÄÓÐÒæÓ°Ïì¡£ÕâЩ½á¹ûÇ¿µ÷£¬AIµÄ×éÖ¯¼ÛÖµ²»½öÒÀÀµÓÚ¼¼ÊõͶ×Ê£¬»¹ÒÀÀµÓÚ²¹³äÐÔ×éÖ¯ÄÜÁ¦ºÍÔ±¹¤Êý×Ö¼¼ÄÜ¡£Í¨¹ý½«ÕâЩ¹¹ÄîÕûºÏµ½Í³Ò»¿ò¼ÜÖУ¬Ñо¿ÔöÇ¿ÁË×ÊÔ´»ù´¡¹Û£¬²¢ÌṩÁËÀ´×ÔÐÂÐ˹ú¼ÒÇé¾³µÄʵ֤֤¾Ý¡£¾¡¹ÜÑо¿¾Û½¹ÓÚ¼ÓÄÉÒøÐÐÒµ£¬½á¹û¿ÉΪÆäËûÑ°ÇóAIÇý¶¯Êý×Ö»¯×ªÐ͵ÄÐÂÐ˹ú¼Ò×éÖ¯ÌṩÓмÛÖµµÄÊӽǡ£Î´À´Ñо¿Ó¦²ÉÓÃ×ÝÏòÉè¼ÆºÍ²»Í¬Çé¾³ÖеĶîÍâ×éÖ¯ÒòËØÑéÖ¤ËùÌá³öµÄ¿ò¼Ü¡£